BCM: I Can Bake A Cherry Pie! Or at least a Cherry Crumb Tart

I waited until it cooled just enough not to scald my tongue. Then, feasting time!

I waited until it cooled just enough not to scald my tongue. Then, feasting time!

This week’s Baking Chez Moi bake-a-long recipe is for Cherry Crumb Tart. In classic Dorie Greenspan style, she starts off the recipe by describing how she came up with the idea to make a tart with cherries after a drive through Alsace, France. As for me, my strongest association with cherries in baked form is that old folksong, which will now be your new earworm: Can she make a cherry pie, Billy Boy, Billy Boy?

The entire time I was making this tart, I was humming the song to myself, albeit with some mondegreens.

Can she make a cherry pie, Billy Boy, Billy Boy
Can she make a cherry pie, Pretty Billy?
She can make a cherry pie,
that’s the apple of my eye,
but she’s a young thing, and cannot leave her mother!   

Eh. Close enough. And speaking of close enough, this recipe calls for a lot of butter (yum!) and since I don’t have a scale, I sort of eyeballed it when the recipe called for 6 tbsp. here and 6 tbsp. there. So my final product may be a bit buttery, but again…eh, close enough. *grin*

Tart crust plus cherries -- it's a gonna be goot!

Tart crust plus cherries — it’s a gonna be goot!

So. The recipe! You start with a sweet tart dough base, partially baked, and fill it with an almond cream. Dorie suggests using kirsch to really bring out that cherry flavour, or otherwise sticking with vanilla extract. Me being me, I didn’t have kirsch in the house, but I did have some leftover red wine, so I used a capful of that, plus a scant tsp. of vanilla extract. The (raw and eggy) filling was delicious with that hint of red wine!

On top of the almond cream-filled tart, you place a layer of fresh cherries. Dorie suggests using a chopstick to pit the cherries if one doesn’t have a cherry pitter. The idea is to keep the cherries whole, so one just pokes the chopstick into the cherry to push the pit out. Can I just say that this is a) a brilliant idea, and b) my poor bamboo chopstick will never be the same again.

Ringed round with cherries!

Ringed round with cherries!

Fresh cherries? Have a LOT of juice. And by a lot, I mean my chopstick is stained a lovely plum colour, as are my fingernails. In fact, both of my hands are sporting a pinkish hue. I mopped up cherry juice splatters from the kitchen island, the sink counter, the tile behind the sink (I was facing the opposite direction, incidentally), the floor, and there were even spatters on my sock-clad feet. At one point, the DH came out of his man cave and exclaimed over the mess I’d made of the kitchen. I chased him out of my working space by threatening to hug him with my cherry-juice stained self and he promptly bolted. Ah, the joys of domesticity!

Too much butter. Or, just enough?

Too much butter. Or, just enough?

Once the cherries were placed on the almond cream-filled tart, it was popped into the oven and baked for a good 45 minutes. Then you pull it back out and put on the final layer: the streusel! Back into the oven it goes for another half hour, until the top is golden brown and the cherries are merrily bubbling away in their juices (or in my case, butter. See above).

Then it’s time to feast!

Verdict: Cherry Crumb Tart — worth the cherry juice stains! Am going to grab another sliver and go curl up on the couch with a book and some pillows. A good book, a cherry tart, what more could I ask for? Life is good. : )

Next Post: My homemade Oreos! Assuming I can find the pieces of paper that I scrawled my cooking notes on. Otherwise maybe my Twisted Spinach and Feta Pie. (I know, I have a thing for pies.)

19 thoughts on “BCM: I Can Bake A Cherry Pie! Or at least a Cherry Crumb Tart

  1. Summer

    What a fun post! I got my husband to sing the song for me and it’s a catchy little ditty. Your tart looks scrumptious. ‘Glad you enjoyed it.

  2. Zosia

    I’m glad the tart was worth the cherry stains. It does look beautiful (and does have a lot of butter – I’m in the minority in this group in thinking it was too much!)

  3. Nana

    I haven’t thought about that song in ages but perfect for this week’s recipe. Your tart looks wonderfully delicious and I am glad you enjoyed it. It was a hit in our house too.

  4. Teresa

    When a recipe calls for this much butter, I just think it’s perfect for sharing – no one person eats too much, that way. I loved this tart and will be making this again, perhaps with other fruits now that cherries are finishing.

  5. Sarah

    I also love the OXO cherry pitter. I can’t even imagine the mess I would have made if I had gone the chopstick route!!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.